Making the Case for Costing Aid: Dean Karlan On Cost Data
What would it take for cost evidence to be as routine in aid decisions as impact evidence? Every year, humanitarian and development organizations make thousands of choices about how to deliver programs: how many staff to hire, which delivery channel to use, whether to send cash in one payment or two. Most are made without knowing what the alternatives would cost. Dioptra exists because we think that should change.
So we were pleased to see economist Dean Karlan cite Dioptra in "The Why and How of Foreign Aid," a new NBER working paper. Karlan describes Dioptra as having made "important inroads" in closing a gap in how the sector reports costs. The mention is welcome. The argument around it matters more.
The core of Karlan's argument is that the field has been reporting the wrong thing. Studies can, at times, take too narrow a lens, or reduce costs to a single figure per recipient. But a policymaker in another country does not pay the evaluated implementer's prices. What they need, Karlan writes, is the quantities of inputs and outputs that make up a program's production function. With those, they can apply their own wages and prices to estimate what the program would cost where they work.
This is the problem Dioptra was built to solve. Our member organizations record detailed input, output and price data in a common structure. That lets a cost analysis in one country inform planning in another. It also supports the operational research Karlan calls for: finding ways to lower the cost of delivering the same outputs, at the same quantity and quality.
Impact evidence tells you whether a program works. Cost evidence tells you whether it is the best use of the next dollar, and how to make it cheaper without making it worse. Harmonized cost data, built up across organizations and contexts, is a public good. It serves the next implementer, the next donor and the next government that wants to know what it would take to do this well.
That is the work Dioptra is here to do, and we are glad to see the case for it made so clearly.
Read Dean Karlan's paper, "The Why and How of Foreign Aid".